WASHINGTON, DC – CFA applauds the CFPB for today’s new proposed rule on overdraft fees. For too long, financial institutions have profited from our financial insecurity,” said Adam Rust, Director of Financial Services for the Consumer Federation of America, “earning billions from high fees that bear little or no relationship to the actual cost of an overage. A bank charter is a privilege, not an excuse to rip people off.”
The new rule closes a regulatory loophole that had permitted financial institutions to offer overdraft services but exempted them from prohibitions in the Truth in Lending Act (TILA). When the Federal Reserve implemented TILA in 1968, it decided to not include overdraft services within the definition of credit. At the time, the practice of covering occasional check overages was a discretionary service extended to customers through manual review. However, with the introduction of the debit card in the 1980s, banks automated the service and introduced them at scale. Overdraft fees morphed into a line of revenue of more than $10 billion annually.
“Banking is supposed to be about making loans, taking deposits, and facilitating payments, but at some point, some banks decided it was also about charging junk fees,” said Adam Rust, Director of Financial Services for the Consumer Federation of America. “The CFPB’S proposed rule restores balance in the relationship between consumers and their financial institutions.
The CFPB’s proposal says that if a bank wants to make obscene profits on overdraft fees, then the service will be regulated as credit, but if it keeps prices to a reasonable and proportional level, it has a safe harbor.
The rule gives banks who want to charge overdraft fees a choice: they can charge a reasonable fee, in which the price is closely tied to the cost banks experience from overdrawn account balances, or they can build a profit-generating overdraft service, but as “covered overdraft credit,” with required pricing disclosures and regulatory treatment consistent with credit cards.
“Ideally, more banks would follow the lead of the ones that have eliminated overdraft fees entirely,” said Adam Rust. “But under the CFPB’s new proposal, while a financial institution can still choose to derive profits from overdraft, new disclosure rules will distinguish it unfavorably from its rivals.”
The CFPB believes the new rules will save consumers at least three billion dollars per year.
Some banks have eliminated these fees, others have reduced the penalty and limited the number of charges, but many other institutions still need to alter their practices. In 2022, consumers paid approximately $8 billion in overdraft fees. Before that, annual fees were regularly greater than $11 billion. However, some financial institutions have never changed their policies, and their dependence on those revenues comes at the great expense of their customers.
See the proposed rule and the corresponding fact sheet.