November 18, 2020 • 2 min read

New Jersey Auto Insurance Premium Comparisons By City

R

Consumer Federation of America recently acquired data that shows auto insurers unfairly discriminate against New Jersey consumers based on their credit scores and in which zip code they live.

In West Orange (zip code 07052), consumers pay an average annual premium of $978.95 if they have excellent credit, $1,621.05 if they have fair credit, and $2,540.35 if they have poor credit. Overall average premium is $1,713.45.

In Newark (zip code 07106), consumers pay an average annual premium of $1,238.45 if they have excellent credit, $2,120.25 if they have fair credit, and $3,376.95 if they have poor credit. Overall average premium is $2,245.22.

In Princeton (zip code 08542), consumers pay an average annual premium of $754.25 if they have excellent credit, $1,200.30 if they have fair credit, and $1,832.55 if they have poor credit. Overall average premium is $1,262.37.

And in Trenton (zip code 08618), consumers pay an average annual premium of $1,090.35 if they have excellent credit, $1,851.60 if they have fair credit, and $2,957.30 if they have poor credit. Overall average premium is $1,966.42.

Related Articles

R
November 16, 2026 / Testimony & Comments
CFA Urges Texas Governor-Elect Gina Hinojosa to Appoint Pro-Consumer Insurance Commissioner 
R
November 10, 2026 / Reports
Blueprint for a Consumer-First Congress
R
November 10, 2026 / Press Releases
Midterm Election Makes Clear, Americans Demand a Consumer-First Congress
R
October 20, 2026 / Press Releases
Top Ten Insurance CEOs Earned Over $155 Million in Compensation in 2025, While Consumers Struggled to Pay Premiums