December 09, 2010 2 min read

CFA Issues Consumer Alert about Auto Insurers that Make Unjustifiably Low Claims’ Payments

PR

The Consumer Federation of America (CFA) today issued a “Consumer Alert” warning Americans who have been injured in auto accidents that the computerized systems used by many insurance companies to process their claims often make unfair, “low ball” claims’ offers. CFA offered advice to consumers on how they could protect themselves from these underpayments.

“Consumers should be very vigilant when dealing with automobile bodily injury claims generated by computer programs,” said J. Robert Hunter, Director of Insurance at CFA. “By adjusting their computer systems to generate claims’ “savings” without adequately examining the validity of each claim, these automated claims’ systems can result in unfairly low payments to consumers.”

CFA recommended that consumers take the following steps to protect themselves from these unjustifiably low claims’ offers:

  • Find out if your offer is generated by a computerized system like “Colossus.”(Allstate is required to disclose this information, but disclosure is voluntary for other insurance companies.)
  • Ask to see the high and low offers generated by the system.
  • Do not accept any offer less than one in the "high" end of the range.
  • If the insurer does not agree to an offer at the high end of the range, consider filing a complaint with your state insurance commissioner or seeking legal help.

Related Articles

PR
August 07, 2026 / Blogs
Oklahoma Has a Major Homeowners Insurance Crisis. The Next Insurance Commissioner Can Help Change That
PR
August 05, 2026 / Testimony & Comments
Consumer Federation of America Urges California Legislators to Oppose Harmful Auto Insurance Telematics Bill
PR
July 30, 2026 / Press Releases
New Analysis: Homeowners Insurance Companies Earn Millions in Interest and Investment Income with Every Day of Claim Delay

Claim Payment Delays Are the Largest Source of Complaints to State Insurance Departments

PR
July 14, 2026 / Reports
Redlined

The Persistence of Racial Inequality in the Cost of Homeowners Insurance